// Blog
17.11.2026

7 myths about the cloud and data sovereignty – fact-checked

Because the cloud has become an integral part of everyday digital life, many companies are asking how much control they actually have over their data. Where is it stored? Who can access it? Which legal jurisdiction governs the provider? And how easily can data be moved if necessary? The tension between efficiency and control, costs and security, has existed for as long as the cloud itself. But geopolitical developments in recent years and the massive growth of the AI industry – together with the associated risks – are once again bringing the question of control into focus.

One term comes up again and again: data sovereignty. Data sovereignty means that companies can decide for themselves how their data is handled at all times – technically, legally, and organizationally.

Server location matters, but it is only one of several factors. Companies need to consider technical, legal, and organizational dependencies together. Even so, individual characteristics are often equated with complete sovereignty. Time for a fact check: These are the seven most common myths about the cloud and data sovereignty that we keep encountering.

Myth 1: “Data stored in Germany is automatically sovereign.”

Hosting and storing data in Germany – ideally exclusively – is an important part of data sovereignty, but not the only one. What also matters is who operates the cloud service, where the company is headquartered, which laws apply to it, and which other companies can access the infrastructure or data.

A server location in Germany alone therefore does not guarantee complete data sovereignty. At a minimum, companies should review the following points:

  • The provider’s headquarters, ownership structure, and applicable legal jurisdiction

  • Locations of storage, processing, and backups; subcontractors involved; and technical and administrative access options

  • Control over encryption keys and data flows, as well as options to export or delete data and exit when changing providers

Myth 2: “GDPR compliance means data sovereignty.”

Data protection and data sovereignty are closely related, but they are not the same. The GDPR, the EU’s central data protection law, governs how personal data is handled and processed. Data sovereignty goes much further: companies must also be able to control their technical and economic dependencies. This includes data export, switching options, access permissions – and the question of how dependent core business processes are on a single provider.

Myth 3: “Encryption solves the problem.”

Encryption is essential for protecting confidential data, but it does not automatically or independently answer the question of data sovereignty. Other factors include:

  • Who controls the encryption keys?

  • What metadata is generated?

  • Who administers the systems?

  • How are backups and recovery managed?

  • Can a company export or delete all of its data?

Good to know: Even a strongly encrypted cloud solution can create dependencies and still fail to provide data sovereignty.

Myth 4: “S3-compatible means AWS.”

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is Amazon’s cloud platform. This matters for data sovereignty because ownership and legal jurisdiction, as well as storage location, play a role. Amazon S3 is an object storage service offered by AWS. But S3-compatible does not mean AWS. Other storage platforms can also provide interfaces based on the S3 API. This allows applications to use S3-compatible storage without necessarily storing data with Amazon.

For data sovereignty, this means: Do not infer the provider, location, or legal jurisdiction from a technical interface.

Myth 5: “An EU cloud is automatically sovereign.”

The label “EU cloud” alone is not enough to ensure data sovereignty, because a data center located in the EU initially tells you only where the data is stored. For a reliable assessment, companies also need to examine provider and ownership structures, legal jurisdiction, technical access options, and subcontractors – see also Myth 1.

EU hosting is nevertheless one of the most important building blocks and a foundation of European data sovereignty.

Myth 6: “The CLOUD Act is irrelevant with German hosting.”

Storage location alone does not settle the question of legal jurisdiction. The CLOUD Act illustrates this particularly clearly: under certain conditions, it requires U.S. providers to disclose data in their possession or under their control – even if the data is stored outside the United States. This can apply even if disclosure conflicts with other national laws – such as the GDPR – or compliance agreements.

Important: This does not mean that U.S. authorities can access data at will. Legal procedures and requirements still apply. But a server in Germany alone does not rule out potential access under U.S. law if the operations or infrastructure are not independent.

Myth 7: “On-premises always offers more data sovereignty than the cloud.”

Running your own servers – known as “on-premises” or “on-prem” – initially promises more direct control over stored data. But a company must also be able to exercise that control in practice and maintain it through ongoing maintenance. This includes security updates, monitoring, backups, redundancy, recovery, and enough qualified personnel.

Cloud or on-premises?

There is no universal answer to whether cloud or on-premises is better. The more important question is which model allows a company to maintain control of its data over the long term and at a reasonable cost. For small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in particular, a professionally managed cloud data room is often the better solution: operations, updates, and all other maintenance costs are already included in the monthly fee – usually with a level of security that an SME cannot achieve on its own.

The key takeaway: Data sovereignty is more than server location

When selecting a cloud or data room solution, companies should therefore consider the whole picture: the provider and its ownership structure, legal jurisdiction, hosting, access and key control, interfaces, and data export and exit options.

Ultimately, data sovereignty means retaining control over your own data and your ability to operate independently in the digital world.

Putting data sovereignty into practice with netfiles

netfiles follows a clear approach: company headquarters, development, and hosting in Germany. This provides clear answers to key questions about the provider, legal jurisdiction, and storage location. Detailed access permissions, activity logs, and other features to protect sensitive business data complement this approach.

Our experts will be happy to show you how to organize confidential data securely and with full control in netfiles, and which solution best meets your requirements.

Schedule a no-obligation consultation now or try netfiles for 14 days – free of charge and with no risk.